Reubens are simply delicious. The combination of sweet/tangy dressing, salty corned beef, sauerkraut and rye bread is just divine. The Reuben isn't a terribly complicated sandwich, but making a proper reuben requires a little work. Nothing too strenuous, just round up the ingredients listed below and you've got yourself the king of the deli sandwiches... We recently made some pretty killer Reubens and I thought it'd be worthwhile to post the recipe and a few pictures. After all, it's almost Saint Patrick's Day and what's more Irish than corned beef? Well, potatoes and a Guiness I guess... but on short notice I'll settle for a Reuben and a cream ale. Ingredients
The be part of the Reuben, in my opinion, is that it doesn't take long to make. You're looking at maybe 5 minutes of prep time before you're biting into the sandwich. If you're in a hurry you can skip the whole toasting step, but you'd really be missing out. So here's what you'll need:
- Soft Rye Bread
- Deli Sliced Turkey Breast
- Corned Beef
- Sauerkraut
- Thousand Island Dressing
- Swiss Cheese
- Butter

We're almost done, now you just need to toast the bread. You could do this ahead of time but I think it's better to put the Reuben together and throw it in a pan so you'll melt the cheese a little more and warm up the meat. This is where the butter comes in, apply a little bit of butter to the outside top and bottom of the sandwich and throw it on the skillet until the rye starts to toast a little. Flip the sandwich when the rye turns golden and give it another minute or two to warm up the other side. I like using soft rye because it won't be too crunchy or hard after toasting like a dark rye. Also, it's lighter in color so you can see it toast a lot easier. So once you've toasted both sides of the Reuben you're all done. Just throw the Reuben on a plate and cut it in half and you're all set. I enjoy my Reubens with a ramekin of ketchup and a cream ale. Steak fries or onion rings are always a bonus. Tonight though, it was more cole slaw and a couple little boiled potatoes.
The Reubens turned out excellent. They were perfectly toasted, tangy and delicious. Total cost for everything ran about $18 (that included the cost of the potatoes and ingredients for a huge bowl of cole slaw). We were able to get almost ten Reubens out of a pound of corned beef, a pound of turkey, one loaf of soft rye and a bag of sauerkraft. Not too bad for such an awesome sandwich.
I love reubens, i like mine with Mayo AND thousand island.
great pics!